John Piper has written a thoughtful blog post in which he
discourages Christians from owning firearms.
He brings up several true points, backed by Scripture, as follows:
1. God has appointed
government authorities to “bear the sword” and enforce justice (Romans
13:1-4).
2. God has called
Christians to leave vengeance to God, and “repay no one evil for evil” (Romans
12:17-21). Instead, we are to love our
enemies and “turn the other cheek” (Matthew 5:38-39, 44-45).
3. As Christians, we
should expect to share in Christ’s sufferings, including persecution and unjust
treatment, which we should bear with joy (1 Peter 2: 19-20, 4:14-16).
4. We are to trust
God for all of our needs (Philippians 4:19).
On a more personal note, Piper states that he does not keep
a firearm, and that he does not know whether he would “shoot my wife’s
assailant” when faced with that situation.
Piper charitably states “I would be very slow to condemn a person who
chose differently from me.”
Piper’s points above are 100% true, and they are backed by
even more Scripture references than those quoted by Piper in his blog post. Nonetheless, I do not believe the above
points lead inexorably to the personal dis-armament of Christians.
1. The use of personal firearms to provide for
your family is both legal and moral.
Piper concedes that “the Lord ordains for us to use ordinary
means of providing for life,” including food, drink, sleep, medicine, and
personal savings. God may call upon us
to give up any of these things at any time, whether by voluntary sacrifice, or
by involuntary persecution. Nonetheless,
in the meantime we are instructed to live quiet lives and work with our hands “so
that you will not be dependent on anybody” (1 Thessalonians 4:10-12). The faithful work of the Christian and God’s
faithful provision together allow us to be generous to those in need (ex. 2 Corinthians
9:13).
We live on a rural homestead and raise chickens, ducks,
geese and turkeys. Sometimes snakes, opossums
and armadillos threaten our flock. When
our dog Missy alerts us to an unwanted pest, my husband John will take his gun
and shoot it. Firearms are an important
tool to protect the animals under our care.
Proverbs 12:10 tells us that “a righteous man cares for the needs of his
animal.” The use of firearms to care for
our animals (and thus provide for our family) is completely moral.
In addition, hunting is a big part of the culture where we
live. John and I did not grow up
hunting, and we have not had much success (yet). Nonetheless, we can appreciate the value of
responsible hunting: spending time in
nature with family and friends; providing food for the family; and keeping animal
populations in balance. Perhaps Piper
and others who live in large cities see firearms through an urban cultural
lens, forgetting that the Bible is big enough to embrace many cultural
traditions.
Guns can be misused, for sure. So can many other things, including
pharmaceuticals and the internet. This
does not mean that Christians must refuse drugs or technological advances. God
and the laws of our country have given us freedom to use firearms to provide
for their families, by killing unwanted pests and by responsible hunting.
2. The use of personal firearms to defend
yourself and innocent victims is both legal and moral.
Self-defense – protecting yourself or innocent victims from
immediate bodily injury – is a basic legal right across cultures. Killing another person in self-defense is
sometimes necessary to stop a greater evil (the murder of innocent victims),
and it is also a useful deterrent to other would-be criminals. There are many studies that indicate crime
goes down with more lenient gun ownership laws.
Self-defense is different from revenge, which involves harming a
perpetrator after the immediate danger is over.
The Bible does not condemn, and in fact sanctions,
self-defense. The Old Testament teaches
that it is not murder to defend against and kill a night-time intruder, since
it is a reasonable presumption that a night-time intruder has evil intent. (Exodus 22:2-3). Queen
Esther saved the Jewish people by proposing a law that gave the Jews the right
to defend themselves and their families, to the death (Esther 8:11). While overseeing the rebuild of the Jerusalem
city walls, Nehemiah posted armed guards to defend against those who would
oppose the effort. He encouraged the
Jewish people, “Remember the Lord, who is great and awesome, and fight for your
brothers, your sons and your daughters, your wives and your homes.” (Nehemiah 4:14).
In his blog post, Piper brings up Luke 22:35-38, where Jesus
tells his disciples that things are about to get dangerous, and they should arm
themselves with swords. Although Piper
tries to explain away Jesus’ words, the most reasonable interpretation is that
the disciples were expected and permitted to defend themselves.
We can all agree that attacking, raping or murdering an
innocent victim is wicked. God has
provided lawful means of preventing these wicked acts (i.e., responsible
ownership of personal firearms). We can
honor God by fighting evil using the means he has provided. The Bible calls us to “rescue those being led
away to death,” (Proverbs 21:11), “loose the chains of injustice and untie the
cords of the yoke, set the oppressed free and break every yoke.” (Isaiah
58:6). It is naïve to think that
rescuing the oppressed will always be non-violent, or that it will always
involve official government authorities.
Again, I am not speaking about illegal violence or revenge, I am
speaking only about the legal right to defend yourself, your family and
innocent victims.
Piper brings up the famous passage in Matthew regarding “turn
the other cheek.” It is important to
note that Jesus is not referring to the threat of death or immediate bodily
harm. Instead, Jesus is referring to a
slap in the face, a personal insult.
Jesus calls us to show love to our enemies by forgiving personal slights
and being willing to “go the extra mile.”
Jesus did not set down a general principle against defending ourselves
or our loved ones from death or bodily injury.
I believe there is Biblical support for the further
proposition that it is a moral duty for fathers and husbands to protect their
families from bodily harm. Paul
instructs husbands to love and care for their wives as their own bodies
(Ephesians 5:25-33). Paul also instructs
the believer to provide for the needs of his immediate family, otherwise “he
has denied the faith and is worse than an unbeliever.” (1 Timothy 5:8). If we are called to care and provide for the needs
of our families, how much more should we protect them from undeserved physical
harm?
3. The use of personal firearms to fight for
freedom against tyranny is both legal and moral.
The Bible teaches that Jesus came to proclaim freedom (Luke
4:18-19). Christ has freed us from sin
and death, the greatest oppressors (Romans 6:6-7, 8:2). Yet freedom from human oppression is also
precious to the Christian life, and to human flourishing in general (cf. 1
Peter 2:16-17). When the Israelites were
slaves in Egypt, Pharoah prevented them from worshipping God in freedom (Exodus
5:1-4). Thus, before God even gave the
Israelites the 10 Commandments, he had to first rescue them from slavery. In the New Testament, the apostle Paul
instructs believers: “If you can gain
your freedom, do so… You were bought at a price; do not [voluntarily] become
slaves of men.” (1 Corinthians 7:21, 23).
Our American founders used their personal firearms to defend
against British tyranny and establish their independence. I understand that some Christians question
whether this action was biblical. Wayne
Grudem does a great job explaining his position that “the American Revolution
was morally justified in the sight of God.”
(See Grudem, Politics According to the Bible, pp. 88-89). Regardless of Piper’s position on the
American Revolution, he and the hundreds of millions of other residents of the
United States over the past 200+ years have benefitted greatly from the bloody
sacrifice of our founders. That thought
alone should give us pause.
The Constitution is the supreme law of the United States
(Constitution, Article VI). The Constitution
protects the right of Americans to bear arms (Constitution, Amendment II). According to the American founders who wrote
the constitution, laws that are inconsistent with the Constitution “are merely
acts of usurpation, and will deserve to be treated as such.” (Hamilton, Federalist Papers, No. 34). The founders believed that personal
possession of firearms would protect our precious liberty from any tendency of
the government to become tyrannical.
They believed that it was both constitutionally legal, and a moral
imperative, for the “free and gallant citizens of America” to “stand ready to
defend their own rights and those of their fellow-citizens” using personal
firearms. (Hamilton, Federalist Papers,
No. 29; Madison, Federalist Papers No. 46).
While Piper denigrates “elevating political extrapolation over biblical
revelation,” we should not sweep aside true and important events in our nation’s
history.
4. Owning firearms is compatible with
love for enemies.
There is no contradiction between owning firearms and loving
your enemies. David was a warrior, and
yet his ownership of weapons did not prevent him from showing mercy to Saul and
other enemies. You can use firearms to
protect and provide for your enemies, regardless of whether they appreciate
it. You can also use firearms to prevent
your enemies from committing crimes that would harm their consciences and have
negative consequences for them as well as for you.
5. Owning firearms is compatible with
trust in God.
If taking medicine is compatible with trust in God, then
owning firearms is also compatible with trust in God. David composed psalm after psalm speaking of
his trust in God to rescue and save him.
“All your commands are trustworthy; help me, for men persecute me
without cause.” (Psalm 119:86). At the same time, David and his men were
heavily armed. As Piper concedes, God
calls us to use the ordinary means of providing for our life, which I believe
includes firearms. This does not mean
that we abandon our trust in God’s protection.
Firearms, like medicine, can and do fail.
4. Owning firearms is compatible with
joy in suffering.
On this earth, there are plenty of opportunities to practice
joy in suffering. While firearms can be
used to relieve some forms of suffering, there are plenty of other difficulties
that firearms cannot touch. Having to
use a firearm to protect a loved one is, by itself, traumatic and a form of
suffering. We can demonstrate joy in
persecutions and sufferings whether or not we own firearms, and whether or not
we choose to use them.
5. There
is a time and a place for everything.
Ecclesiastes tells us that “There is a time for everything,
and a season for every activity under heaven:
a time to be born and a time to die, a time to plant and a time to
uproot, a time to kill and a time to heal…a time to love and a time to hate, a
time for war and a time for peace.”
(Ecclesiastes 3:1-8).
King Saul unjustly persecuted David, his loyal soldier. Saul tried to kill David multiple times and
chased David into hiding. David had at
least two opportunities to catch and kill Saul unawares. Yet both times, David said, “…may the Lord
avenge the wrongs you have done to me, but my hand will not touch you.” (1 Samuel 24:12, 26:23). In
that situation, David chose to forbear using arms for personal revenge.
On another occasion, the Amalekites raided David’s
settlement at Ziklag. The fighting men,
including David, were away preparing for battle. The Amalekites captured and carried off all
of the women and children. After asking
God for guidance, David pursued the Amalekites and rescued the captives (1
Samuel 30:17). Of course, this also
involved fighting and killing a large number of the Amalekites.
We need to be careful not to add or subtract from what the
Bible says (Deuteronomy 12:32). The
Pharisees were guilty of adding additional requirements to God’s law (Mark
7:3-4), which served only to oppress the people and obscure God’s true
requirements. I believe that there are times when God calls individual
Christians to give up their rights, including their rights to gun ownership and
self-defense. But this does not justify
discouraging gun ownership more broadly.
False guilt and hand-wringing over gun ownership is
counterproductive. Rather than
encourage Christians to disarm, we should encourage Christians to use firearms
for God’s kingdom. “You my brothers,
were called to be free. But do not use
your freedom to indulge the sinful nature; rather, serve one another in
love.” (Galatians 5:13).
I appreciate John Piper's thoughts on this issue, and the Biblical truths that he has expounded. At the same time, I know many faithful, believing men and women who value the "gun culture." This brief essay is intended to give those men and women some comfort in knowing that their way of life is not condemned by Scripture, and is compatible with obedience to God's commands.